Micron, Samsung and SK Hynix Fail to Get Memory Cartel Suit Dismissed
Saturday, November 147 Min Read
A federal judge in California let a class action proceed that accuses the three firms of jointly restricting DRAM supply. The ruling coincided with a Monday in which Micron fell 7.62% and SK Hynix 7.89%, while SanDisk, not a party, dropped 8.58%.
697%
Alleged 18-month Price Increase
Over 91%
Three Firms' DRAM Revenue Share
17
Consumer and Small-business Plaintiffs
December 7
Companies' Answer Deadline
Companies in This Piece
In This Piece5 Sections
Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California, in a ruling dated November 14, denied in full the motion by Micron, Samsung and SK Hynix to dismiss the case. The plaintiffs allege the three firms jointly restricted the supply of conventional DRAM memory.
The ruling landed on a weekend, and the market saw it on Monday. On November 16 Micron fell 7.62% and SK Hynix dropped 7.89% in Seoul. Nvidia slid 4.12% the same day.
What the Plaintiffs Allege
The suit was filed on June 25. The plaintiffs are 17 consumers and small businesses who bought memory inside PCs or memory kits rather than directly from the makers. They are seeking class-action status.
The claim rests on four parallel moves. SK Hynix and Micron announced output cuts three weeks apart in the fall of 2022, and Samsung followed on April 7, 2023. All three then shifted production toward HBM, the high-bandwidth memory stacked next to AI chips.
According to the ruling, HBM uses three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte of conventional DDR5. The third move was the April-June 2025 announcements of a DDR4 wind-down. The fourth was all three adopting near-identical customer vetting questions in January 2026.
What the Court Said, and What It Did Not
The stage matters. At this point the judge accepts the allegations as true and asks only whether they are plausible enough for the case to proceed. There is no finding that the companies did anything wrong.
At the hearing the defendants cited Judge Posner's line that rivals in concentrated markets watch each other like hawks. Wise replied that the allegations are "more akin to hawks flying in formation."
She did not accept every allegation. Because Micron kept making DDR3, she set the DDR3 claims aside. She wrote that the HBM pivot alone might not suffice, but that together with Micron's December 3, 2025 decision to shut its Crucial brand it tipped the balance.
The court did not say the companies are guilty. It said the case has earned the right to move into discovery.
Price Increases Compound, They Do Not Add
The ruling lists the contract price increases the plaintiffs cite: 50% in the fourth quarter of 2025, 93% in the first quarter of 2026 and 58% in the second. Added together, those come to 201%. But each increase sits on top of the last, so the real result is far higher.
The plaintiffs' 697% figure also covers retail prices; the ruling says retail prices rose 500% since October 2025. If supply did not expand while prices climbed that far, the plaintiffs argue, that is a signal in itself.
Monday's Selloff Had More Than One Cause
Memory stocks fell almost twice as much as Nvidia on Monday. But SanDisk, which is not a party to the case, also lost ground that day.
SanDisk makes NAND and is not named in the suit, yet it was the biggest decliner. That suggests the selling spread across the whole memory group. Nvidia's leadership crisis and a 10-year Treasury yield above 5% also weighed on the day.
Seoul Economic Daily listed the ruling as one of three factors behind the Kospi's 3.59% drop. The sources do not separate how much of the decline came from the lawsuit.
The companies' defense was that AI demand drove prices higher. The judge found that explanation insufficient for the customer vetting, because the vetting began after AI demand and the HBM shift were already under way.
Case Timeline
- October 26-November 16, 2022SK Hynix and Micron announce output cuts three weeks apart.
- April 7, 2023Samsung joins the production cuts.
- April-June 2025All three announce a DDR4 wind-down.
- January 2026All three begin using similar customer vetting questions.
- June 25, 2026Seventeen plaintiffs file a class action.
- November 14, 2026Judge Wise denies the motion to dismiss.
The industry's history is also in the record. In the 1998-2002 cartel investigation Samsung paid a $300 million fine and Hynix $185 million, while Micron received immunity as a whistleblower. The court noted that this history is not a finding in the current case.
The Nasdaq 100 chart below is live and counts back from today; it helps place Monday inside the broader tech move.
What It Means for Investors
- The market priced the case on Monday alongside Nvidia and rate worries; SanDisk's drop shows the selling was not specific to the lawsuit.
- Micron is the only U.S.-based defendant; Samsung's and SK Hynix's direction also drives pricing of U.S. memory stocks.
- The January 12, 2027 hearing will decide whether internal emails and capacity-decision records are opened up.
- The risk to this thesis: if the firms document that the cuts and DDR4 exits were independent, the case could later end on summary judgment.
Sources: Case details come from the November 14, 2026 order in case 5:26-cv-06345 in the Northern District of California. The plaintiffs' price claims come from the complaint as summarized in the order and are unproven. Stock moves come from market recaps, and Kospi data from Seoul Economic Daily. The companies had not commented at the time of reporting.
Companies in This Piece
Since The Event